Rajya Sabha explodes as Nadda, Mallikarjun Kharge trade barbs over Rahul Gandhi, 'gag' on opposition

Congress party Agar birthday suna chahta hai ha muska nijeet uska choice kya hai Mein uska chahta like in Baki members So Prime Minister Kabashan suna chahta after the senior after the experience AATA leader of the house Rahul Gandhi ko. Bhattachya. Aapne. Party go abode balaka bandak bhat banai bandat madmaniye don't make hostage of the party yahar abriman ahankar or abode hokar ke abode or ahankar yeah dono bra deadly mixture OTA to ise bachkar kar hai or party ku Banda na bana de ifna mera nivedan hai AAP party ko Sachin group chalaye or above balaka Banda. Party hai aapki party to aisi hai kisko bone Kaine aapko to Modi. Abhi Leader of Opposition karke jiya achara puttkarke team din say rastapati Ji kavi vasant par dhandavat prastav ka charcha main both Moody Rajya Sabha. Go on, regard actually, leader. Democratic principles. Sargeji ko aaj yeh baat ragna para teen Deen ka chacha hum sabe sula or jaise ka Rajya Sabha main Leader of Opposition Pradhan Mantri Bollesse pehle who apna baat rakhenge usko bhi humlog de Madai chairman Sir aapke mojit main aapke chair by top. We all party cup floor leaders cup business advisory by top or hamne jaisa Congress party request kya hamne mana karge Ji ka bashan jaise Thai kiya gayata Kal bashan diya PBM apathy Leader of the House Devi apna bhat raka aaj chota dile 4th day of the discussion on On the motion of Thanks to the honourable presidents address to a joint session of the Parliament. We all are expecting that all the honourable members will follow the traditions and the rules. This house belongs to all the honourable members. All the members are waiting to listen this speech of honourable Prime Minister today. Yeah, Congress party Agar for government baat dei suna chahta hai. Hum muska nijeet uska choice kya hai. Mehska thopna NE chahta like in baki members so Prime Minister kabashan suna chahta hai. Dusra Lok Sabha ka so proceeding say uska hawala yahadiya leader of the house ladaji nape kedia dusa sadan kaja proceeding hai. Uska yaad jikar nahi kablache yeah. Upper House, Council of States Yeah rules, Rajya Sabha ka rules of business conduct karne ka tarika parai lekin AAP ka Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha new name ante rules. After the senior, after the experience. Leader of the house, Rahul Gandhi. Yeah, Upper house. Upper House the the. I. Am your people. Jaise jaise business chala chaya alak siya Mahal khara karnika courses mat kije aaj or bakila Bola bhakiya. You go to your seat first. Why? You first go to your seat. I know, Lop. You all go to your seat first. You all sit in your seat. I will give you Sir, one minute. I will give you honorable leader of the House. You want to tell something? Let him speak. OK. Now. Yes. Sir, hum samaste Ki. Let him say something, then later the house is here to respond why you are worried about. Sir Hum House court disturbed nahi Karnataka lake in. Are you? You tell the truth? No, you are telling. Against the truth, Sir. When asked immediately I asked you to speak or people are coming and shouting. This is the democracy. Charge char din SE wo house binay chalra kyo Ki yellow pico bolen nahi terai like in Hamara kaina yeh hai Ki dono house Mila ke baadi apartment Ek house apartment nai banta yeh donus Tam hai. Yeh donus Tam hai yeh paralyze kar ke AAP apne aapko chupani Kali apne kaltiya chupani Kali AAB Jo kar hai kiye hai is desh kujo doka dere desh Ki Jo apman kare uske bhare Mein jab Rahul Ji bolte. Hai Ko should not be want to tell something. Proceeding. Proceeding. Then you know everything, Sir. And you you know that Lok Sabha proceedings cannot be there in Rajya Sabha, but that you know very. Well. And again, and is not Parliament should. Be then I. Have to say that please be democratic, even yesterday. All. Were talking come the numbers they are telling Lok Sabha independent we should be allowed to Why the minister has not made his statement in the Rajya Sabha? This was your. Her Kanwan, her bill was a past Sonic de Padi. So you see. Now. Okay, one minute you can. Speak, let him speak. Then you can speak. Now. You people. Please. Then then I will give you time. Them say Congress party or desh ko bhi yes pash Sandesh dena chahta Hun K mania Pradhan mantri Modi Ji Ki nethu tume chalne Wali Sarkar har same har tari ke SE charcha karne ke liye or discussion karne ke liye. Lok Sabha me Jo Bate huni uska jawab Lok Sabha me habare sadan kineta or sansadiya Dal ke neta or desh kineta Prahan mantri Modi Ji wahab jawab deniki tayar bathe hai. Lok Sabha ko aapne chale nahidiya ham ham ham jahata Raja Saba ka sabal hai. Ran Mani sabapatiji jatak Rajya Sabha ka sawal hai. AAP lekha. Indo U.S. trade deal per statement though. Toran. Huge goals in a state statement. The statement may AAP Ki ruling thi kismap koi sawal jawab nahi hoga. This is a statement and it is a so Moto statement. It was given aapne bucha to hamne bataya ke trade deals ke contours wo tayar ho hai or wo AAP batadiya jayega aapne charcha char din rashtrapatiya vibhasan par Ki mania Leader of the opposition name appraise sameko SE beast minute adik Bola jitna Bola chahta boli yaha Ek ache Mahal mean or democracy khatre Mein or yeastre Ki bachit karna yeah bilkul ghalat hai or iska main khandan karta pujo khandan karta hum har tari ke. Southeast Charcha. Ki yaar hai or Mein deepaks ke neta ke Madam say yehana chahunga ke jab hamare houseman sari Bate karne kili hum tayar hai and we are ready to go on every minute details. Let the discussion take place. AAP hamse bhat senior hai or AAP SAB main bhat selo hamseb senior hai Like an Ek Batman zuru nivedan karunga apni party go abode balaka bandak bad banaya bandak bad banaya AAP don't make hostage of the party AAP AAP AAP dekhiye ethne samandar. I am asking to speak why everybody is rising. Please wait. Let him complain, Samandar. Hai or kar hai ke AAP ko thi kaab ko party kender bhi is baat ko samjhana chaye ke democratic democracy mahi humko Kam karna hai yahar abhiman ahankar or abode hokar ke abode or ahankar yeah dono bra deadly mixture OTA to say bachkar kar hai or party ku bandak na bande de ifna mera nivedan hai AAP party ko sachan group chalaya or above balaka bandaka Hola DJ is Ki chintaki. Now. Now you want to speak? Yes, please, the opposition place. Like in unone Ki Ek ABI Jo adult naha nabalik kuch apne Hindi. So. I see, I see. Bathe Bhullah E Khandani or dusri cheese hamare. Party me karma you want? To condemn the slogans of the other side also, Sir. And if you are speaking, all your people are coming towards you. This is the correct. No, when you. Deny the chance for you to speak, then everybody is rising. I can understand when I called you to speak. All the people are coming. No, no. They are not coming. They are very silent. I like them. You like them, but you like them after your seat not nearing to you. Sir, I like them. I do like them I. Dislike them so? Dislike them? What I can do? I am not asking you to like them. But if you. Just like Sir. I agree mujhe AAP Jo pat padar hai Ki Lok Sabha Mein Jo hota hai. Yahabar utana uchit nahi my puchna Jada Agar parliamentary democracy Mein charchar din Parliament Agar opposition leader ko bone ke liye nahi de Tai aur mahabhar Jo mudhe utai jaat hai. Yapar was suski charcha hoti UP independent nahi Lok Sabha Rajya Sabha a mil ke Sarkar banati a mil ke raithe hai Like we are House of elder Sir and House of Elder ke Chairman. No, I'm very proud. Key You are chairman of the Elders. Elders and Joe Mai Unko Ek Nath bar par mat toko kit Mari party hai hai. Aapki party to aisi hai. Kisko bone kainai aapko to Modi jina Banda kardiya hai AAP koi unke Rai ke bina batnai kar sakte AAP koi Jo Bola hai. Bandak means bonded labor, Sir, bounded labor, Lokdar bane to, E Lok to. Kapil No, no, no, no, no. This bonded lover will not go on record. You cannot you. Cannot call as bonded. No, no. But I will not agree. I will not. I will not agree there. Is a act so bonded labor act? That is. In BJP. Here that is, but you cannot call the honorable members as bonded lovers. That is not correct. Not. Sir, I am not. Calling OK, OK. Sir, Sir. Mare ko Ek to AAP yellow opposition party ke Mehta ko bone nahi our dusri cheese hum. One minute, 1 minute, you call honorable Minister Parliament. I will complete, Sir. Okay, you complete I. Will complete Rijuji I'm the time both milta hai Sir mera kaina is nahi. You can't criticize says yes, our party may ka chala hamare party kya AAP ke jaisa yeah apna lynching karti hai ke aapke jaisa kisi ko kalya de jaisa karta hai karta hai karta hai parliamentary. No parliamentary. Will. Not go on regard, no wrong against the norms. Rules will not go on record. I am not saying anything. I am just saying if anything is wrong against the rules, norms of the Parliament that it will not be there. Will not go that. Please, please, please take your seat. Sir, you complete. I can ask her. That's right. From my only question. You are disturbing the matters raised with permission. You are disturbing the individual. I'm not disturbing, Sir, I am just pleading before you that how these people are crushing the democracy. And how? These people are not allowing the opposition leader if that is the fate, elected members. What about the nominated members? Persons who got indirectly elected, indirectly elected and nominated. So in Ki halat kya hogi you don't. Agree. I will quote one minute 1. Minute you please take your seat. Debates in Lok Sabha Members should not make any critical reference about the debates in Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister Sriman Jawarlal Nehruji has suggested that it should not be made a practice in the Council to refer to the debates in Lok Sabha and that even though it might be justified, technically it was not. It was bad practice, Lok Sabha discussing the council and the Council discussing the Lok Sabha, leading to trouble between the two Houses. I would ask you not to refer to the House, the reference that you have made to the other House. Will be. Expansion through the proceedings. This is the ruling of the chairman of that. Time No. No, no, Sir, Sir, Sir, I agree. Why? You are getting why you are getting so agitated. You are getting so much of time beyond the Tri-City benches. I am giving you a lot of time, but even then you are getting agitated. I don't understand if you want to put anything in your speech. You put you ask your leader of opposition to sit and you can speak. Sir. But you don't want then letting him speak why you are intervening. Sir aapko, target? Target or yellow democracy? Opposition should put their their opinion. They are taught everything in the house. At the same time, Trishani Pinjas is also having their own right defy your thinking. They have right to answer to your questions. They have right to answer to your opinions they have. Nehruji, most Nehruji, most democratic man. Not these people. These people are only criticizing Nehruji, Indira Gandhi. They are missooting their power. Their missooting. Their house that. Is not in this House. That has not happened. Even the Presidents address negligee has been prized. You might have noted. Noticed it now I ask. No, no, no. Now I ask. No, I ask. We. Don't want to listen of? Parliament. Yes, Aapko. Leader of the Opposition to Ijat Dekhi Chairman Extra ordinary aapko Bulanda Yeah. Southern, Southern aapko Aapko or Hamaram Chalega or Yeah, wait to know. That is what I'm saying. He has taken the time again and again. This house belongs to everyone. You can't take all the space all the time. Sir #1 kargaji the mislead kya is sadan football. Take a leader of the elders bana jata hai. You misled the House AB de Bola ke waha Leader of Opposition Lok Sabha ku bolen idea Yeah AAB de mislead kya kusko 40 minutes tuck Charlie's. Minute Tuck Usko. Speaker le time diya rules bahar bahar Bah speaker the ruling the Barbie nahi month away or are you a mislead number? 1 Please, please wind up. Please wind up number. 2 Leader of Opposition said that if Lok Sabha doesn't function, how can Rajya Sabha function? He also said that the both the houses run together which is absolutely wrong. If Leader of Opposition can show me one rule that if Lok Sabha gets adjourned, Rajya Sabha should be automatically adjourned, show me the rule. These two houses may constitute together for the Parliament, for the functioning of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. They are guided by different rules and there's no precedent that if one House gets adjourned, the other House should also get adjourned. There's no such tradition. No such rule out of Guru. Suddenly today why Congress party has taken up this issue of what is going on Lok Sabha we have allowed you to speak after speaking all your time, you want to disturb honourable Prime Minister? What tactics is this? We condemn this tactics of these of opposition.